The April 30 deadline for filing a personal income tax return is not that far off (see
list of this and other tax deadlines from the Canada Revenue Agency) so it is a good time to talk tax. Today, we discuss common types of fixed income.
Not everyone holds fixed income investments in tax-free or tax deferred accounts such as a TFSA, RRSP, RRIF, LRIF, LIRA, RESP etc, though one should do so if at all possible. When fixed income is held in a taxable account, the income must be reported every year. Some calculation and reporting is easy and some is fairly intricate.
Misconceptions - First, let's clarify a few points about fixed income that might lead people astray.
- Income subject to tax is not the same as cash received - You may not receive any cash, yet still have income to report, especially income such as capital gains within a mutual fund or ETF (e.g. see previous post The Mystery of Capital Gains in 2008 Explained). No cash is received till maturity from strip bonds or compound GICs. Fixed income funds regularly generate taxable income that differs from the cash distribution, as a quick look at the distribution detail of the iShares DEX Universe Bond Index Fund (symbol: XBB) shows.
- Taxable income often includes more than just interest - Witness the XBB tax breakdown, which shows everything but dividends - interest, aka other income in tax parlance, capital gains, return of capital. The return of capital component is unique to funds (arising because of the way that money flows in and out of the fund - see our post on ROC for an explanation) but individual bonds can throw off capital gains if they are sold or mature for more than their purchase price.
Guaranteed Investment Certificates (GICs) and Canada Savings Bonds (CSBs)Tax reporting is easy.
The financial institution where such investments are held sends you a T5 with the correct amounts to transfer onto your tax return. In the case of compound GICs or CSBs, where the interest cumulates and is only paid at maturity, you still must, since you are legally entitled to receive it, report the income year by year as if you had received it, and the T5 includes it.
In the case of cashable or escalating GICs where you may receive a lower rate of interest if cashed in early, the interest is reported year by year as if you were holding to maturity. If this maximum rate is not achieved, then the loss difference is reported as negative income in the year it happens.
CSBs and GICs never have a capital gain or loss since you always receive back the exact principal amount invested.
Coupon BondsThe most common type of corporate and government bond bears interest coupons that are structured to be paid twice a year six months apart. Since current required rates of return or yields fluctuate constantly and never exactly match the coupon interest rate,
coupon bonds will produce both interest income and a capital gain (or loss) whether held to maturity or sold before maturity.
Two situations are possible when buying a bond. In one case the bond asking price from the broker is above the standard $100 par value, which is when the coupon interest rate is above the current yield. That is the case today for almost every bond on the market as current record low interest rates have increased the value of bonds issued in past years far above their initial price. These are called premium bonds. The other case is the opposite - bond price below par and bond coupon interest below current yield - and such bonds are called discount bonds.
The best way to explain how the taxes work is to use examples.
Premium BondsClick on the image below to enlarge the spreadsheet.
Our example bond is the Government of Canada bond with a 5% coupon paid twice a year on June 1st and December 1st as 2.5% (half of 5%), or $250 of interest on our supposed purchase of $10,000 worth (called face value) of bonds. Since the coupon rate is far above current interest rates on offer, manifested as the 1.999% yield, the price of the bond per $100 of par face value is, not surprisingly, much higher at $109.313. If we place our order on March 11, 2011, the cash and ownership trades hands three business days later on March 16th, the settlement day.
Part of the total price to pay for the bond is the interest owing from the previous regular payment date, in this case December 1, 2010. This $143.84 of
accrued interest is important for taxes. The amount of accrued interest is pro-rated as the number of days times the per-day coupon rate, in our case 5% x 105 days/365. From an investment return point of view accrued interest matters only as a question of timing of cash flow since the $143.84 that we pay out to the previous bondholder is recouped on June 1st when we receive the full $250 in interest, not just the portion earned while we have owned the bond.
Discount brokers will normally show the accrued interest on the online quote and the trade confirmation sent to the investor. In counting days of interest, a buyer excludes the settlement day, while a seller includes it (see section 3.3 in
Canadian Conventions in Fixed Income Markets).
Tax Calculations:
Interest Income
- Accrued interest paid on purchase is both included in, and deducted from, income (i.e. net zero income) in the tax return for the year - Since we must report the full $250 in interest received June 1, 2011, we get to deduct the $143.84, i.e. only the $106.16 we actually earned is net added to our year's income.
- T-slips show only the coupon interest on purchase; the accrued interest appears separately as an "amount paid by you "in the year-end summary statement sent by the broker for inclusion as an expense on Schedule 4 of a tax return.
- Accrued interest on sale before maturity for inclusion in reported income occurs also up to and including the settlement day of the sale
- T5-slips show the accrued interest on sale.
- Coupon interest payments (cash received) are all included in reported income
Capital Gains
- Accrued interest is excluded from the Adjusted Cost Base (ACB) of the bond - ACB is not the total purchase price of the bond.
- Capital loss will occur if the premium bond is held to maturity, no matter what happens later to interest rates. The capital loss occurs in the year of maturity and may be reported then to offset other capital gains, or carried forward or back.
- Sale before maturity will change the capital gain or loss depending on the movement of interest rates. When interest rates rise the capital loss will increase - scenario B in our example - and when they fall the loss may turn into a gain - scenario C.
- All capital gain or loss calculations must be done by the investor him/herself; the broker does not do it or put it on T-slips for you. The T5008 information slips issued by brokers to investors show only the proceeds of disposition and not the ACB.
Discount BondsClick on image to enlarge spreadsheet.
Our discount example was hard to find - the Government of Canada 2% coupon maturing 01 June 2016. The coupon is slightly below the 2.45% yield so the price is $97.88 per $100 par value.
Tax Calculations:
The rules are, of course, exactly the same as for premium bonds regarding calculation of interest income and capital gains. The spreadsheet works through the numbers.
What is important is the fact that
the discount bond produces a lot less of its return in the form of interest than a premium bond. Some of it is capital gains and that is deferred until maturity or sale. (Note that a capital gain is not guaranteed if interest rates rise in the interim before sale, as our Discount bond scenario B shows.) The fact that a premium bond naturally produces a capital loss for taxes in effect means that it generates too much interest income. The investor ends up paying more in taxes.
A discount bond is thus inherently better than a premium bond from a tax point of view.
TaxTips.ca constructs a hypothetical example that shows how much tax advantage a discount bond can have over a premium bond with the same yield. TaxTips' recommendation makes sense:
in a taxable account, to minimize taxes, choose the bond with the biggest discount.
Possible Future Opportunity - Interest rates / yields are still at long time lows. When they inevitably sooner or later rise, bond prices will fall. There will be many more discount bonds. If interest rates rise strongly, the discount will be even higher and longer maturities will experience the greatest price fall. A greater and greater part of the return on bonds will consist of capital gains, deferred till maturity or sale. That will reduce taxes for the investor. For investors who do not need the income flow,
discount bonds could become a very tax-effective holding, especially highly secure Government of Canada bonds, which also tend to have the lowest coupon rates.
Treasury BillsT-Bills do not pay any interest. Their return comes from being purchased at a discount to the standard par maturity value of $100 per T-Bill (though the minimum purchase amount at discount brokers is usually $5000). The return when held to maturity is considered to be interest by the CRA. Since by definition T-Bills always mature within a year, the easiest way to account and report the interest is for the tax year the T-Bill matures, though the taxpayer / investor could choose to accrue part of the interest, following the method explained below for Strip bonds, in each tax year for T-Bills that straddle two tax years. The broker does not report on T-slips the interest. The broker reports the proceeds of disposition on a T5008 slip. It is up to the investor to do the step of subtracting the ACB to net out the interest.
Strip BondsStrip bonds are created when investment dealers or other financial institutions take normal bonds and separate (i.e. strip) each interest coupon and the principal into individual securities that can then be bought by individual investors. For detail on how strip bonds work including tax treatment, see the excellent
Strip Bonds Information Center by financial industry insider Keith Campbell.
The essence of taxation is the same as for Treasury Bills. There is no on-going cash flow but the CRA forces tax to be paid each year based on the implicit return an investor receives, which is the yield to maturity at purchase. The return is considered to be interest income for tax purposes, which attracts the highest marginal tax rate. The fact that taxes have to be paid every year at the rate for interest income, while the investor only receives the cash return up to decades later, is the reason
strip bonds make most sense in a tax-deferred / tax-free account.
Our example spreadsheet below works through the tax calculation for a strip Government of Quebec maturing 01 June 2014 with a quoted yield of 2.306%.
Tax Calculations:
- When held to maturity only interest income results. The on-going cumulation of interest to the ACB means that no capital gain or loss occurs at maturity.
- Capital gains or losses can result if the strip is sold prior to maturity after interest rates / yields go up (resulting in a loss) or down (resulting in a gain). The calculation must still add the year's accrued interest accrued up to the date of sale to the ACB before netting out the gain or loss, as our scenarios B (loss) and C (gain) show.
- As with T-bills, the broker will send the investor T5008 slips or capital transactions summaries with proceeds of disposition but the investor must do the interest calculation him/herself.
Disclaimer: this post is my opinion only and should not be construed as investment or tax advice. Readers should be aware that the above comparisons are not an investment or tax recommendation. They rest on other sources, whose accuracy is not guaranteed and the article may not interpret such results correctly. Do your homework before making any decisions and consider consulting a professional advisor.
